Enter the ageing Dragon…..
by Bromme Hampton Cole 柯 博 明
中国龙进入高龄化社会
同 志 好! This is China Senior Living’s inaugural blog. Here, you will read about my opinions on the state of the industry, new events, conferences, project updates and other relevant matters. At first, my entries will be posted randomly and time goes on I will attempt a more consistent and frequent blog. I also intend on having industry icons as “guest” bloggers as well. But first things first…
This is China Senior Living !
As a general statement, senior living today in China is a trend and a trend that is consigned exclusively to the upper end of the market. In all fairness however, it is a trend with extraordinary facts that underpin its potential; all of which evidence and corroborate a likely near term transformation into a full-fledged industry. These realities are:
1) Demographics: China’s well known and highly publicized demographics indisputably show that it is facing a dramatic transition from a young to an aged society in the coming 10 to 20 years. In 2000, there were 88,110,000 persons aged 65 years and older, which represented 7% of the population. Today this figure is closer to 150 million or 13% of the total population; and by 2020 those over 65 will total an astonishing 265 million. There are no official statistics that account for the relative wealth of those in this age cohort, but it is safe to say that the overwhelming majority of those over the age of 65 are rural poor. Less than 10% could be considered middle class (western standard) and a corresponding 1% deemed wealthy.
2) 4-2-1: Because of the peculiar 4–2–1 family structure in China, one can expect that older Chinese adults will increase their use of senior living facilities in the coming years. With the China’s burgeoning economy, the lure of prosperity and the consumerism that follows, it is unrealistic to expect that the remaining one child will remain at home to care for the elders. Additionally, the Chinese government has realized that a) it is financially unsustainable to expand in this area using public resources and b) they have no real understanding of gerontology as witnessed by the government’s “Star Light Program” and the “Beloved Care Engineering” launched in 2001 with suboptimal aged care services to say the least. The government’s current policy, outlined in both the 12th 5 year plan and the recent Circular 58 legislation is to encourage private and foreign investors to participate in the retirement housing business in China.
3) Filial Piety: The Chinese tradition of caregiving for older family members is and has always been an inward looking phenomenon; they rely on family members to support all aspects of an elder’s care. This is what the Chinese refer to as the value of “filial piety.” In fact, China’s constitution mentions that “…Children have a duty to support and assist their parents…”. While most of the younger persons in China still maintain the attitude that taking care of the older family members is their responsibility, more and more of China’s youth are unable to provide all of the family support functions and require some outside assistance. This is due in part to the 4-2-1 phenomenon mentioned above as well as the impact of China’s prosperity and the consequential trend of small nuclear and empty-nest families.
Yet these facts which will transport the trend into an industry are constrained by a single, stark reality; there is no geriatric health care operator currently in practice in China with the knowledge base that is required to adequately care for a frail, elderly population. This is not to say that there are no such facilities, indeed there are and at last count, I have found and visited about 25. However these facilities are real estate plays and/or strictly independent living opportunities with little or no care services (to wit: Golden Years in Hangzhou). Alternatively, there are facilities that have attempted aged care services but the reality of caring for a frail census far exceeds the ability of the hired staff whose training is simple nursing. The point here is something I have tweeted about previously and is an axiom of the senior living business in China:
The tipping point that transforms China senior living from a trend into an industry is the development of “localized” operators who have assimilated and culturally integrated the fundamentals of aged care into an acceptable Chinese context; simply translating western operating manuals into Mandarin is doomed to fail.
Alas, I think it was Confucius who once said that necessity is the mother of invention and indeed there is at least one geriatric care operator in formation at present and should be open by late next year. This nascent operator will open his doors in a flagship prototype specifically designed for long term aged care. It will be a small facility, which not doubt puzzles the Chinese given their propensity for Freudian accomplishments, but going forward the operator plans to offer contracted services only…..A brilliant move. I need to also mention another facility that is truly a model of Chinese senior care (near) perfection. General’s Garden in Beijing is a CCRC that is at least 5 years ahead of anything else in China built to date. This is not to say that there aren’t issues or mistakes as there are, but from a design and service POV, GG takes the CSL Blog Award for outstanding facility!
All the above is to fully suggest that there is enormous opportunity for western senior living companies. However, the opportunity must be approached with humility, patience and a willingness to fully adapt your care programs to a Chinese sensibility and temperament: this is elemental, essential and of liminal importance.
In my next blog, I am going to address the existing facilities in more detail; their pricing structures, business models as well as how I see western operators being successful in China. Subsequent to this, I plan on discussing the watershed Circular 58 ruling in greater detail as well as a primer to the legal vehicles one might use to enter and exit China in the senior living business.
Thanks. I hope to hear from as many of you as possible.
NOTE: Retirement Communities World conference is in Hong Kong this year. It is being held on October 10-12. I urge all who are interested to register at Terrapinn’s website. www.terrapinn.com
Bromme,
First of all, thank you for the affirmation of our General’s Garden, especially you are an experienced experts in the senior living industry, we feel it a great honor from your affirmation, the GG will continue efforts to create high-quality senior living communities.
There in no doubt those Western experts’ specialty and experience in senior living industry, but can not just rely on western operating manuals, but to understand the needs of Chinese senior living market and the customary operation mode well in China, however, both Chinese and Western management team need to have run-in period, and then create a most suitable operation and management mode for their senior living business, that is two combined in one then both creates a win-win situation.
Bromme, I have to say, you are very conscientious with enthusiastic into this industry. And precise with study, analysis of past cases and the reality of the present situation also provide a lot of useful information, give the investors and operators of great help, I admire you very much, and look forward to reading your next blog.
首先谢谢你对我们将府庄园的肯定,尤其你在养老产业中是一位经验丰富的专家,有你的肯定我们感到十分荣幸,将府庄园将持续的努力打造高优质的养老社区。
西方养老产业的专家在管理经验与专业上是毋庸置疑的,但不能只依靠西方的管理运营手册,而是要了解中国养老市场的需求,以及本地运营商在管理上惯有的操作模式,中西两方管理层要有一定的磨合期,再共同创造出最适合本身的养老运营管理模式,也就是二者合一,共同创造双赢局面!
你非常认真而且热情的投入这产业,并且严谨的分析、研究过往的案例及当下的现实情况,提供很多有用的讯息,给养老产业的投资者及运营商很大的帮助,我对你十分的敬佩,期待能在你下一个blog中与我们分享更多的讯息。
Thank you Miranda! I hope to do a much larger review of General’s Garden in the near future. Perhaps you can send me a photo or two of General’s Garden? I will return to Beijing shortly and hopw to meet with the owner.
Thank you!
Bromme!
“The tipping point that transforms China senior living from a trend into an industry is the development of “localized” operators who have assimilated and culturally integrated the fundamentals of aged care into an acceptable Chinese context; simply translating western operating manuals into Mandarin is doomed to fail.”
Bromme, Trying to understand what you mean by this quote? Dont you think any type of western operations manuals can serve as a starting point or a reference, from which the Chinese can implement yet improve upon.Of course they will integrate these ideas into their own culture? Skilled Care for the aged takes specific training and knowledge but skilled compassionate care, in and of its self, is spoken with a universal language, no matter the culture. Those suffering with AD or Dementia need care from those who have an understanding of where the disease is going and from my knowledge the disease behaves the same, no matter which continent you are on.
Hello Monique!
I am trying to borrow Malcolm Gladwell’s phrase here to describe what it is going to take to convert senior care in China to a real business, short cuts won’t work.
Western manuals can serve as a conceptual basis and at times maybe even more that just a basis. But I have see so many westerners just land in Beijing Capital Airport and attempt to dictate the rules of a venture to the Chinese only to find out that they have spent a great deal of money for naught; the arrogance of Westerners can be astonishing. Understand that much of the terminology in a gerontology manual has no Mandarin equivalent….there isnt even a good word for gerontology in Mandarin. So how does a translation work if there are no such words? Well, the translators make up the words….or try and describe what they think is being said in English (afterall they are translators and not nurses) and the resulting translation is a disaster! Now you also said “skilled compassionate care, in and of itself, is spoken with a universal language, no matter the culture”…..my response to this is yes and no. You must begin to grasp the concept that EVERYTHING in China is different….EVERYTHING….so the way one approaches a frail elderly (body language) is completely different. But bear in mind that the Chinese will likely not accept a foreigner to administer care or medicine…this must be done by a Chinese person. So, your “skilled compassionate care” for the elderly patient must be taught to a Chinese nurse because they never learned how to care for the elderly in such a way that you are describing. The notion of “caring” and “service” are two concepts that are just being discovered now in China as it pertains to the elderly.
China today is like America in the 1950′s….there is so much opportunity.
Thanks for reading. Please subscribe if you want to hear more!!
I will be back in Shanghai/Beijing in early September. Let’s connect then!
Thanks for starting this discussion. Fascinating because the numbers are mind boggling to have so little in place to address this issue. Would you mind explaining more about the 4-2-1 concept?
Many thanks for your comment. Here is what 4-2-1 refers to:
In 1978, China instituted a “one child policy” in an attempt to reduce what was thought to be a burgeoning population. Whether or not this was true it is difficult to say, but the policy was somewhat controversial and may have led to other ethical issues. Nevertheless, 4-2-1 refers to one of the unintended consequences of the One Child Policy, namely that there is only one child to care for/look after six people….two parents and four grandparents. It is unique to China and very widespread…the problem dominates the demography issue and leads people like myself to conclude that children will need to avail themselves of assistance to care for their ageing parents and grandparents.
Wikipedia has a great page on all this…check it out: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-child_policy
Thanks again for listening here. I will be posting a great deal more as there is so much to cover. Please subscribe to the blog if you like!!!!
Bromme! 柯 博 明 !
Great initiative Bromme!
Subscribed and shared in social media.
Thanks
Thank you, Oscar. Your comments and suggestions are welcome!
I have spoken to many Chinese people and friends including ministry of health officials. They all said that the West can not move and copy their care concepts and models into China without modification. China needs its own care model and this model can only be developed in China.
Emerging opportunities of the senior living industry in China are enormous!
Exactly. And those Western companies who have grasped this concept are doing very well and entrenched in this opportunity presently. Western firms can make money in this business….it is all about how they pursue it!
Hi Bromme,
Thank you for bringing up this issue. Aging care including senior housing is an emerging industry in China with huge profit space for investors.
You mention filial piety which I think is a prior consideration for western investors than demographics or the 4-2-1 since western investors need to make people, senior parents and adult children, psychologically accept senior housing first before selling the houses and services. As you mentioned, children will be considered irresponsible or feel guilty themselves if sending their senior parents to senior housing. I think partly it is because of the negative image of earlier senior housing (e.g., terrible services, cheap environment, loneliness, irresponsible children, death out of home), and partly because senior housing challenges the traditional model of a Chinese family, which is highly integrated and tightly connected from both geographical and emotional levels. I have visited some senior houses in the United States. From the standpoint of a Chinese granddaughter, I feel that western older adults feel happy to live on their own rather than depending on their children, which is on the contrary to Chinese parents, who prefer to be economically supported and physically taken care by children. To importing senior housing into the mainland Chinese market, there are lots to do with localized services.
It’s very encouraging to see that senior living industry is emerging in China right now which also means more opportunities for us young professionals.
Look forward to hear more from your blog.
Thank you Tammy. Today, senior housing in China is a phenomenon for the rich only. And while the rich in China may be a small percentage of the total population, that number is actually quite large. My experience shows that most of the rich have been westernized to some degree if not by virture of their wealth then by their children who have largely been educated in the west or work in the west (or have worked in the west and been repatriated their companies). This westernization has made them comfortable with the lifestlye of a senior community. I truly think the filial piety issue only is a major impediament with the lower middle income and rural poor. The second reason I feel filial piety is not the impediment that it once was (for this socio-economic class) is that China is rapidly becoming a prosperous nation and a consumer society. For better or worse, the hallmarks of such economic development is a looser family structure, parents and siblings become more far flung. This is NOT to say it is less tight or less devoted to each other, just separated more frequently by the distance that one’s job imposes. For this reason, the security that a senior housing community offers, make total sense and the children understand this.
I had a conversation with a well off young Chinese man in Beijing three weeks ago and asked him why he encouraged his parents to take a flat at a very nice senior community. He said, “I am in London most of the year and my parents are frail, if some thing happens I want the proper medical attention to ber there for them immediately.” True……but I think he also enjoyed making his parents friends jealous over the fine accommodations he gave his mother and father…..this is the new filial piety!
Hi Bromme,
I’m very glad to have found this Blog. It is a very interesting matter. As a professional in eldery living and care, working in this field for over 15 years in Holland, I see the urge to rapidly start to develop the right facilites for elderly. My partners and I in Mangrove Int. developed a concept that is proven succesfully t in the western world and more specific in Holland. We work form the wellbeing approach and not the medical approach. In our opinion well being comes first. if elderly live in a lively environment they will need less care. It is a total concept and not to be described in 10 sentences. The concept we developed is called Mangrove. We are preparing now fir the first facillity to be developed in the MENA region. In Cairo only there are 1.6 million elderly and hardly any facilities for the. We need to rush to give an answer to the need of these elderly. We see more and more countries now that face the same problem. China is on of the, of course. Our concept is ready….we are ready for the market. We do not develop real estate only but implement the concept. That is our starting point. Investors are welcome in this fast growing market with great opportunities.
Elly de Heus,
Dank u wel, Elly!
These thoughts are very confident and I like them. I am also eager to learn about your concept mangrove and learn how it can be applied to the China market.
I look forward to learning more about your firm next week during our call!
Dooei!
Bromme!
I think a hospice concept will work best for China. This will allow the family to feel empowered and have control over their parents care and keep their parents in the home for as long as possible. I don’t think Chinese will do so good in Western style living facilities.
Also, since the current healthcare system in China is pay to play; I see significant issues with regard to class discrimination in the coming years. There are around 200 million + migrant laborers in China who send money back to parents faithfully. These people can be segmented into low wage construction labor, low wage factory labor, technical school labor and college graduate labor. They struggle with the current system and issues are going to arise between the government class and rich Chinese who have much greater access to resources than these groups. Migrant labor will have a very difficult time caring for parents because of geographic separation. The parents will have to be moved to region of migrant labors work. And this will further swell China’s over populated cites and strain hospitals to the breaking point.
Thank you for your thoughts Jameses!
While I agree that hospice has a future it is difficult to say what works best for China. If I have learned anything it is that China is not a country, it is a world….meaning it is so utterly diverse that simple labels or superlatives as to what is best or most or biggest aren’t necessaryily true and if they are they don’t last long.
I disagree on two of your points. First, Chinese (and definitely the upper class Chinese) will do well in senior living facilities that they have “sinofied”. Second, I think the government will have to accommodate the migrant workers but this task will not become a problem for another 10 years. Already the insurance companies, such as Ping An, are exploring ways to offer long term care solutions for the rural poor on a rental basis. They are also experimenting with certain types of long term care insurance to facilitate this expense.
I think China will find its way and a their own solution here. In the meantime we in the west have an opportunity to assist with IP in this industry.
Thanks again Jameses! I look forward to hearig from you again!
Wow, Bromme, doing a great job and lots of comments already, congratulations in this initiative, it’s obviously meeting the market demand
Thanks Moira! I appreciate your support!
What a great contributions of you all. I agree with you that we cannot just copy a western concept and drop it in China. Our keyword should be ‘Demand driven’. it is not the professionals who decided what elderly need, it is the elderly themselves. We just have to bring solutions for their needs.
This implicates that we have to set aside the western arrogance, indeed.
I worked for Humanitas in Rotterdam, Holland. Our concept was so innovative that many, many visitor form all over the world, yes, also from China, came to see and hear about our vision.We use this concept now in Mangrove Int. We just started to build up the organisation but already we find several countries to be interested in this. So many countries share the same problem of an aging population. It is like a ticking timebomb. We have to take measurements in time to deal with this issue.
All True Elly! Thank you for your contribution here!
Great review! This is exactly the type of post that should be shared around the internet. Sad on the Google for not positioning this article higher!
Many Thanks!
Bromme, thank you so much for your astute comments and insights. Although I have not been to china since 1978, I have felt that too many westerners think their way will work for everyone. The arrogance is quite astonishing. Each culture has it’s own idiosyncrasies, but china has a culture far different from any other country.
Correct me if I’m wrong but I think it is a law that you must support your parents. I heard that parents can sue their children for lack of proper support. the gentleman from london that put his parents in a very nice apartment was the envy of his peers. This might be a very realistic trend?
Also, what about the concept of multi-generational living communities with services to support the various demographics. U remember the Chinese developer that spoke at our coference last year in Singapore who lived in his home with four generations. This is more the norm in china, a concept westerners have abandoned and sadly so. For we are missing out on the connectivity, the story-telling, the wonderful impact that grandparents can have on our children. Just as an iPhone can’t constitute a relationship, you can’t put a price tag on life experiences.
I think there are solutions, but westerners need to delve more into the fabric of the Chinese culture that has been in play for thousands of years… Another concept westerners find hard to comprehend.
Thank you. I hope to see you soon and let’s explore a joint-venture with min! I hope you are enjoying time with your son upstate. Cheers, Adrienne
Ps when at deutche bank did you happen to know my cousin johan Fredriksson out of the London office?
Adrienne!
It may be a law, I am not quite sure. But law or not, the socio-economic strata of middle income/rich China is changing rapidly. This isn’t to say that they will no longer “look after” their grandparents or parents, it just means that it will be in a modern context….a “modern filial piety” as I explained in my blog.
Yes. The concept of intergenerational housing that we heard so much of back in Nov of last year in Singapore is not yet fully found its translation, as a living arrangement, into China yet. Remember, one of the things that came to light in that conference as well was the extent to which the Singapore government encourages such living arrangements; it is very curious indeed. Whether or not it can find its way there is to be seen. As you know there are worlds of differences between China and Singapore….similar ethnicity….but vastly different societies.
As for your cousin, Johan at Dbank, I am afraid I do not know him.
Thanks so much for checking in here!
Illuminating, Bromme, excellent work!! Patience and communication will be critical. Assistance on the IP level will be an exciting opportunity for many in the industry. Appreciate your leadership…!
Much appreciated, Chris! True, patience and communication are indeed virtues in this cross-cultural context. Also true is how critical a role technology (tele-care, especially) will play. Over the last 30 years, China has often “skipped” over status quo technology….witness their leap past land line telephones and the present ubiquity of mobile/wireless technology. The same will apply to senior care; to the extent such technology can be utilized to save money and time it will be. Next blog is in about a week!
My regards to all who have posted so far and, accepting that everything said regarding the limitations of applying western care & management models to provision for elders in China, I do believe there is useful best practice available from care facilities set up for and run by the expat Chinese communities in the West. I am aware of two such facilities in the UK which have successfully combined western settings with Chinese cultural practices with a team that is bilingual, (as their residents are almost all non English speaking). An opportunity to learn from very relevant experience here – maybe via staff exchanges?
Welcome! Thank you Ian for these comments and in large part I agree with you. I also am aware of facilities in the US (located in or near Chinese-American communities). These have all the traditional hallmarks and cultural affects that one would expect. However, they are not fully “Chinese” as the census is made up largely of westernized persons. Yet, I have to admit they are “halfway” there. Your point of tapping these facilities as brain trusts is an excellent one. Thank you.
Bromme, the two facilities I am aware of in the UK are occupied by Chinese who only moved here in later life to be close to / help their middle aged children. These are very much a non assimmilated group who did not learn English or adopt a western living style and, significantly, they are not being fully supported by their children as they become frail.
This has left the Chinese community with the challenge of providing care & accommodation for people who are ‘fishes out of water’ – ie they are in a strange country with no ability to engage with the UK benefit system or with society in general.
It has therefore been very tough for those attempting to provide support to these Chinese expats, as they have to find staff who have the cultural sensitivity and language skills yet can only pay the same low rates as the general UK care industry, (due to being tied into the government pricing frameworks for most of their services).
Interestingly, these facilities have become excellent resources for comparative work on the effects of ageing among differing ethnicities, highlighting the relative healthiness of Chinese and their very different lifestyles and preferences when compared with other groups in mono-cultural settings.
The choice of leaving your country as an older person to be with your family who cannot fully support you and thus having to enter a radically different care system, with all its unknowns, must be extremely stressful.
Wow, very good to see such knowledgeable discussion from your blog. I have to keep updating myself about the industry in order to improve my expertise.
Thank you Lisa! I appreciate. Kudos to all who commented…they have raised the quality of the discussion greatly!
Hi Bromme, Great to read your input and after your AAIF 2011 presentation this Blog is a great way to continue the discussions that we so found so interesting and stimulating. As you know we(Inis Homecare and Consulting, the Netherlands) are very interested in developing home care operations for elderly in Asia. Two weeks ago we showed delegates from Singapore a new , small scale, living model with life long care possibilities. It was good to learn more about their view on developing aged care.
Even though we’re no specialists in the Chinese Health Care market we’ve been following the information you posted and the discussion’s following with great interest and enthousiasm. We see this period as a period of innovative thinking and development of ideas, discussion and analysis of a health care market which is so complex and new for all. Your advice on entering the Chinese health care market with humility,patience and an open mind seems like the right thing to do.Let’s be honest: the West can also learn from this new market ,as we made our health care costs almost unpayable and the costs are still rising.
We spoke witha few developers from China, Malaysia and Singapore about home care development. We are in Kuala Lumpur in August to continue our research. For now, our contacts seem to be interested in training and coaching for their nurses and health care managers. Can you tell us more about how Western operators, like Inis Home Care, could support Chinese operators in the development of a Chinese model?
In the Netherlands and other European countries we have a social system which helps pay for the nursing home and home care bills for everyone: rich or poor. This is not the case in China or most other Asian countries. How can we offer the right care model for everyone in China, regardless of income levels? Is this what the government is aiming for in the next decade?
We think home care could be one of the models that could work: costs are much lower, and it can be introduced into allready existing retirement living developments. What ‘s your opinion on that thought? How would Chinese react to receiving home care?
I hope this blog will develop into a beautifull think tank of doctors, developers, nurses, consultants and financers. Thank you for setting it up. We hope to meet you again soon, sadly not in HongKong in October. We’ll be focussing on KL and Singapore for now.
Ies Paalvast
Inis Home Care & Consultants
Rotterdam, The Netherlands
Ies,
Very good to hear from you again! It sounds like you are making progress since we met at AAIF in Singapore.
Here are my thoughts on your comments: First, other than the CCRC facilities Yanda and General’s Garden there are really no Chinese geriatric operators. Your niche here, I believe, is to form a JV with a developer and structure compensation both as consulting fees and for delivering service. But beware, offering geriatric operations in China is complex; not from a regulatory POV, but from a cultural one.
On your “model” question, your statement “…regardless of income…” doesn’t apply. At the present, private facilities only are available for the rich. Will this change? To a certain extent, but as I will discuss in my next blog, there are other solutions on the horizon that will offer care solutions for rural poor and low income persons.
Again, the issue of home care fits squarely into my next blog…..I have to maintain some suspense and anticipation!!!!
Best to you!
Dooei!
Hi Bromme
you talked of the government having no understanding of gerontology, indeed you noted there was not even a good word for gerontology in Mandarin. you mention the governments unsuccessful attempts to address the issue of care for the elderly in 2001 (star light programme) and the current idea of encouraging western operators and investors to lead the way in this field. Does the Chinese government not have a statutory duty to provide care for its most vulnerable citizens?
Also, how do we define care? In the UK, care is a response to a particular need and these tend to be categorised as physcial health, mental health, emotional well being, sensory impairment, mobility problems, looking afterself, looking after others. The current approach is to maintain people in their homes until the risk of self neglect or accidental self harm means it is not safe for them to live on their own. This comes from a need for local government to save money but also an acknowledgement that most elderly people would prefer to remain at home with support then to enter a 24 hour care environment. The current focus is on empowering the elderly to identify their own needs and direct the packages of support they require. In essence it is the elderly themselves who choose what assistance they will have.
Who is driving this agenda in China, the elderly themselves or their children who will have to support them? You will have to forgive my ignorance but in a modern Chinese family who actually decides what happens to the elderly? and what rights do the elderly have?
One last question; how would you define ‘Chinese sensibility and temperament’?
Thank you Andy! This is among the best of comments I have recieved to date.
The answer to your first question, “Does the Chinese government not have a statutory duty to provide care for its most vulnerable citizens?” is no…I believe the constitution mentions care of elders as a duty of younger generations….but not an obligation of the state.
I agree with your definition of care….it isnt much different in the US….maybe more of a focus on recieveing “care” in a facility.
Who is driving this agenda? Long answer: the impetus comes from many directions all of which have come together at a similar time to create something of a perfect storm effect. The government’s mention of the demographic challenge in the 12th 5 year plan certainly was a momentum builder as was the recent liberalization of the health care law in Circular 58 which gave foreigners the ability to deliver medical care in China. These two factors would be sufficient to explain the frenzy in my book, but there is another powerful motivator here as well. That being senior housing is not considered real estate in China and therefore exempt from certain regulations governing the purchase and finance of homes. Such categorization also allows foreign funds and investors to use certain offshore “tax advantaged” vehicles to invest in these projects, which are no longer permitted for “real estate”.
As for Chinese sensibility and temperament…..This is a dissertation that I am not qualified to write….I am familiar enough to know it when i see it but not yet able to articulate it quite yet. It can take a life time to fully understand the cultural implications of 5,000 years of history.
My advice here is to go see or read “The Joy Luck Club” by Amy Tan. That will give you an amazing insight into what the Chinese are like. In a few days, i will post my next blog where I write briefly about this subject.
Thanks again Andy…..great comment!
Bromme!